The Sidebar ~ Scenes from inside the El Paso County courts

Archive for the 'sex assault' Tag

Live from the Riley trial: accuser testifies

December 1st, 2010, 2:18 pm by

Richard L. Riley. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette

Hello court watchers,

This is John Ensslin, legal affairs reporter for the Gazette. 

This afternoon, I’ll be live blogging from the trial of Richard L. Riley, the parole officer accused of sexually assaulting a female parolee.

The woman who brought the allegations against Riley is on the witness stand.

The woman claims she had sex with Riley twice, once at her Colorado Springs apartment and later as a Denver motel.

Riley’s lawyers say the incidents never happened.

The Gazette, which normally does not identify alleged sex assault victims, is withholding her identity.

 Click here for a story from August, when the woman testified at Riley’s first trial. That trial ended in a mistrial.

Prosecutor Jennifer Viehman is asking the woman about the incident at her home.

Viehman asks if the woman ever said no to the sex.

No, she replies.

“Why not?” the prosecutor asked

“Cause I was scared that I’d go back to prison,” she replied. “And at the time, I didn’t want to ruin his career. I felt sorry for him.”

“He, in my view, was the best parole officer I’d ever had…and I liked him.”

Viehman asks why the woman eventually came forward with her allegations.

“I couldn’t live with the guilt anymore,” she said.

“Were you trying to get out of a hot U.A. (a urine nalysis that detected drugs or alcohol, which could have resulted in a revoked parole)

“No” the woman answers, covering her eyes and weeping.

“Has this been a difficult process for you?” Viehman asks.

“Yes,” the woman replies.

The prosecution has finished questioning the woman, who has been on the witness stand most of the day.

The court has taken a 10 minute break. When we resume, Riley’s lawyers will have a chance to cross examine the woman.

Gregory Maceau. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette

We’re back.

Defense attorney Gregory Maceau is cross-examing the woman about her criminal history.

She admits to experimenting with drugs by age 15 and getting her first felony conviction in 1994.

She said she can’t remember everything from that period.

“I was a full-blown drug addict at the time,” she says.

Maceau also asked about other charges including false reporting and vehicular assault on a police officer.

“You ran over the officer’s foot while trying to avoid arrest?” Maceau asks.

“Yes,” the woman sobs.

Maceau asks why she didn’t tell someone about her situation with Riley, specifically an 83-year-old former police officer whom she had befriended.

“You could have gone to him?” Maceau asks.

“Why would I do that?” she replies.

“Well, you claimed you were trapped,” he says.

“I didn’t know who to trust,” she says.

Maceau asks about the alleged incident at the Denver motel.

He asks why, if Riley’s appearence at her workplace in Denver that day was a surprise, would he arrange to get a motel?

“Your guess is as good as mine sir,” she replies.

Then why did she go? Maceau asks.

“He’s my parole officer. I do what he tells me to” she replies.

Maceau asks about the sex at the motel.

“You’re reciprocating. You’re as passionate as he is? the lawyer asks.

Yes, she replied.

Maceau asks if she wanted to have sex that day.

“I was torn,” she replies. “Because I didn’t, but I did,” she answers.

Maceau asks if she previously testified that “You wanted to prove to him that you weren’t wearing a wire, so you took all your clothes off?”

Yes, that sounds right, she says.

The woman has asked for a break.

 I’ll end this live blog segment here so I can check on the other two trials also underway.

Law links, Veteran’s Day edition

November 11th, 2010, 11:36 am by

Hello Court Watchers,

The courts are closed today in observance of Veteran’s Day.

But it’s been a busy week already in terms of interesting court stories in the news.

So here for your holiday reading are some links to those stories.

First off, my friend Andrew Cohen at CBS Radio News had this interesting column on the 10th anniversary of the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Bush v. Gore. (It seems amazing to me that those 10 years have gone by so fast.)

From the Atlantic Magazine’s website, here’s a column on the prospect (slim) of getting cameras in the court room for oral arguments before the Supreme Court.

The National Journal had this amusing story on the possibility that lame duck Florida Gov. Charlie Crist might issue a pardon for the late rock-n-roll musician Jim Morrison.

You may have read about a jury in Connecticutt giving the death penalty to a man convicting of killing several members of one family. But check out the post-verdict video on the New Haven Register’s website. It’s one of more poignant and moving statements I’ve ever seen by a crime victim following a trial.

The New York Times had this interesting story on reaction to that same death penalty case from members of the jury.

One of the most fascinating trials underway this week is the kidnap-rape case against a man accused of abducting Elizabeth Smart in Utah. My SPJ colleague Ben Winslow has been covering the trial and provides this insightful almost annotated transcript of Smart’s testimony.

Today being Veteran’s Day put me in mind of the fact that the sacrifices made by our armed forces have afforded us the freedom to try these issues in our legal system, a freedom that we shouldn’t take for granted.

So have a good holiday and happy reading.

John C. Ensslin

Legal Affairs reporter

The Gazette

Reaction to the Allmon verdict

November 10th, 2010, 4:46 pm by

Here’s some reaction from Senior Deputy District Attorney Laurel Huston, moments after a jury convicted Willie B. Allmon on all charges in the rape-murder of his grandson.

Laurel is a bit soft-spoken, so you might want to turn up the volume.

Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Also here is Laurel answering a question from a reporter out in the hallway.

Neither the Allmon family nor Willie Allmon’s public defenders were available for comment after the verdict.

Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

The Daily Docket

November 10th, 2010, 9:56 am by
Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Know of a court story I ought to be covering? Let me know. My e-mail: john.ensslin@gazette.com

John C. Ensslin

Legal Affairs reporter

The Gazette

Notes on the Allmon trial

November 9th, 2010, 6:58 pm by

Willie Allmon (left) and Deputy Public Defender Todd Johnson. Photo by Mark Reis/Gazette

 

A cell phone trail

Both sides in the first-degree murder/sex assault trial of Willie B. Allmon made use of an extensive record of phone call and text messages between his daughter Felicia Allmon and her ex-boyfriend.

 Deputy District Attorney Melissa Young used the tower locations of the calls to track Felicia Allmon’s 14-hour drive from Killeen, Texas to Colorado Springs as a way to prove her whereabouts.

On the morning her 8-month-old son Isiah was killed, those calls showed she was heading to her mother’s house an hour before her father called to report Isiah had stopped breathing. That meant the boy was alone with his grandfather at Willie Allmon’s Widefield home for the hour in which prosecutors say the child was fatally injured.

Deputy Public Defender Todd Johnson used the sheer volume of calls and messages to illustrate the turmoil of Felicia Allmon’s life in the hours leading up to her son’s death.

Felicia Allmon testified during the trial that her relationship with Isiah’s dad was over. She also said they were able to settle a dispute over the Pontiac she used to drive Isiah and his older brother to Colorado.

Johnson challenged that testimony by going one-by-one through the call record.

“Look at that,” he said, showing the calls on a projector screen. “This isn’t over folks.”

What the video said (or didn’t)

Both sides also gave their own interpretation of the 3 hour plus videotaped interrogation of Willie Allmon by El Paso County Detective Bill Otto.

Johnson asked the jurors to remember how Allmon was trying to provide an explanation after Otto tells him of the boy’s severe injuries.

“You saw Willie Allmon struggling with that,” Johnson said. “You saw Willie Allmon trying to figure out what had happened.”

“He’s praying to God to help him understand what happened on his watch based upon incomplete information and inaccurate information,” Johnson said.

Deputy District Attorney Laurel Huston

Deputy District Attorney Laurel Huston had a different view of the tape.

“He’s struggling in the video because the story he was telling everybody wasn’t adding up,” she said.

Huston also pointed out something not in the video or in Allmon’s other statements.

She said he never asked about how Isiah was doing.

The trial resumes at 8:30 a.m. tomorrow. Stay with The Sidebar for updates and the verdict.

Jury deliberating grandfather rape/murder trial

November 9th, 2010, 9:57 am by

Deputy District Attorney Melissa Young. Photo by Mark Reis/Gazette

Background: Willie B. Allmon, 52, of Widefield is on trial on charges of first-degree murder and sexual assault on a child in the May 18, 2009 fatal beating of his 8-month-old grandson Isiah Wilson.

What happened: After nine days of testimony, the jury heard closing arguments this morning.

Deputy District Attorney Melissa Young told the jurors that Allmon is the only person responsible for the child’s injuries.

She disputed his explanations that he passed out and fell on the child while changing a diaper or accidently bumped the boy’s head on a kitchen counter.

“We know that the defendant’s explanations for the injuries that the child suffered don’t make sense,” Young said.

“This was not one minor act. This was significant force,” she continued. “It’s from a slam. It’s from a throw. It’s from a hit. It’s from some sort of blunt force trauma.”

Young reminded the jury that medical witnesses testified that the boy’s injuries occurred within an hour of his arrival at Memorial Hospital. That was a period in which Allmon had been left alone to care for the child.

Deputy Public Defender Todd Johnson. Photo by Mark Reis/Gazette

Deputy Public Defender Todd Johnson agreed that’s Isiah’s death was not an accident. But he argued that Allmon’s daughter Felicia, the child’s mother, was the more likely suspect.

“Isiah died from child abuse. No ifs, ands or buts about it,” Johnson said.

“Willie Allmon was just a sick man trying to help his daughter because Felicia Allmon was in an extremely difficult emotional situation,” he added.

Johnson recalled how Felicia Allmon had just broken up with Isiah’s father Jarried Wilson and had drove back to Colorado Springs from Killeen, Texas, where Wilson was based at Fort Hood.

Johnson described a constant stream of phone calls and text messages in which Felicia Allmon and Wilson were arguing about the car she had used to drive back to Colorado. Johnson also recalled how Felicia Allmon’s mother had been filing complaints against Wilson with his Army superiors.

“Felicia Allmon had lost control of her life,” Johnson told the jurors.

“The evidence points to Felicia Allmon,” he later added. “Felicia Allmon was the one who was stressed. She’s the one who’s life was being torn apart…She’s the one who had been up all night,”

“No one is saying she’s cold, evil or didn’t care,” he added. “But sometimes normal people do abnormal things when they are in stressful situations that are spinning out of control.”

What’s next: The 9-man, 3-woman jury began deliberating shortly after noon. Stay tuned to the Sidebar and gazette.com for updates and the verdict.

The Daily Docket

November 9th, 2010, 8:47 am by
Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Know of a court story I should be covering? Let me know. My e-mail: john.ensslin@gazette.com

John C. Ensslin

Legal Affairs reporter

The Gazette

Allmon trial nearing the end

November 8th, 2010, 12:57 pm by

Willie B. Allmon (left) and Deputy Public Defender Todd Johnson. Photo by Mark Reis/Gazette

 

The first-degree murder and sex assault trial of Willie B. Allmon is nearing the end.

After nearly 8 and one-half days of testimony, the prosecution rested its case on Monday.

Allmon’s public defenders will present their evidence this afternoon.

Closing arguments are likely to start Tuesday morning.

Allmon, a 52-year-old retired Army sergeant from Widefield, is accused in the fatal beating and sex assault of his 8-month-old grandson Isiah Wilson.

Stay with The Sidebar and gazette.com for the outcome.

The Daily Docket

November 8th, 2010, 8:30 am by
Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Know of a court story I ought to be covering? Let me know. My e-mail: john.ensslin@gazette.com

John C. Ensslin

Legal Affairs reporter

The Gazette

The Daily Docket

November 4th, 2010, 9:54 am by
Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Know of a court story I ought to be covering? Let me know. My e-mail: john.ensslin@gazette.com

John C. Ensslin

Legal Affairs reporter

The Gazette