The Sidebar ~ Scenes from inside the El Paso County courts

Archive for the 'marc sylvester' Tag

Scenes from the Nozolino hearing, part two

February 14th, 2011, 5:12 pm by

Bruce J. Nozolino

Prosecutors claim the four shootings they have charged Bruce Nozolino with carrying out were “sniper shootings”, a relatively rare thing statistically speaking.

But public defenders representing the 49-year-old anti-tax activist contend that they are not so rare in places like Colorado Springs with a high number of military personnel.

At a hearing Friday they cited two other recent cases involving high-powered weapons, the second-degree murder conviction of Marc Sylvester

and the first-degree murder conviction of Jomar Falu-Vives.

They also raised questions as to whether one of the shootings – the shot fired at the Palmer Lake home of divorce lawyer John Ciccolella – actually was a sniper shooting.

“The evidence they (police) collected at the scene of the first shooting is so minimal that we take issue with the characterization that it is a sniper shooting,” Deputy Public Defender Carrie Thompson told Judge William Sylvester. Later she added, “There is no real evidence that all four of these are sniper shootings.”

Thompson also challenged another prosecution claim, that Nozolino told one investigator – during the execution of a search warrant – to tell him what he was being investigated for so that he could come up with an alibi.

That was “natural language” for anyone in Nozolino’s situation, she argued.

In effect, Thompson said he was saying, “I have to know, so that I can defend against this group of people who have been investigating him over and over again.”

A shoot plan

Attorney John Ciccolella described the night a sniper shot him in the eye while urging Sylvester to set the highest bond possible on Nozolino.

At the time of the shooting, Ciccolella represented Nozolino’s ex-wife in a particularly nasty divorce.

“I felt a shot going through my body that was so strong that I knew I was dying and that I had only seconds of consciousness before I died” he said.

His wife Pam Ciccolella credited her son Chad – who was working with his father in his downtown law office – with saving his father’s life by stopping the bleeding.

“He initially thought that John’s head had been blown off,” she told the judge.

John Ciccolella told Sylvester how he obtained a weapons permit after the shootings and slept at night with a 9mm handgun and body armor nearby.

He talked about how schools and other families work out an evacuation plan in case of fire.

“We had a shoot plan,” he said. “When the bullets start flying, where do you go? Who do you defend?”

“We practiced that and changed it as the boys grew older,” he added.

“I understand the court’s ruling,” he later added. “I understand that you have to follow the law.”

“But we will not be safe,” he said.

Ciccolella said Nozolino showed during the bitter divorce proceedings that he would not follow court orders.

“He makes his own rules and interpretations,” the lawyer added.

As an example, he said Nozolino was ordered at one point to turn over a blender to his ex-wife.

“He gives her the blender, but not the top,” Ciccolella said. “It’s not a blender without a top.”

When Ciccolella finished, Sylvester told him, “There’s no way I can understand what you and your family have gone through. I don’t think anyone can comprehend it.”

Perjury charges still sealed

On Friday, prosecutors added two felony counts of perjury against Nozolino.

However, the details of those two charges are still unknown. The court clerk’s office said Monday the affidavit remains sealed from public view even though they were released to Nozolino and his public defenders.

During Friday’s hearing, there was some discussion that Nozolino would need a separate attorney for the new charges, owing to the fact that Deputy Public Defender Carrie Thompson might be a witness in the case.

Stay tuned. All of the cases have been continued until a further hearing on March 18.

Scenes from the Sylvester sentencing

June 1st, 2010, 3:58 pm by

Deputy Public Defender Rose Roy

 

At the sentencing hearing today for Marc Sylvester, Deputy Public Defender Rose Roy cited her client’s military history (four years with the Navy) and his problems with methamphetamine in asking Judge Robert L. Lowrey for leniency.

“It’s clear that he’s in need of treatment,” she said.

She noted that Sylvester has a 14-year-old daughter.

“He (Sylvester) is devastated at the impact this is going to have on her,” Roy said.

She also noted the defense theory that investigators arrested the wrong person.

“The court knows our theory that Ms. (Elizabeth) Angel is responsible for killing Ms. (Jennifer) Warren and that Ms. Angel is the one who should have been charged,” Roy said.

Lowrey gave defense attorneys’ until July 1 to file their motion seeking a new trial based on Angel’s April 22 arrest. Prosecutors will then have until July 15 to respond.

Here’s what Deputy District Attorney Jack Roth had to say following the sentencing:

Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Sylvester gets 48 years in “execution-style” slaying

June 1st, 2010, 2:12 pm by

Mark Thomas Sylvester during his trial. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette.

A judge this afternoon sentenced Marc Thomas Sylvester to 48 years in prison – the maximum – for the February 2009 second-degree murder of a 35-year-old Colorado Springs woman.

Prosecutors said Sylvester “executed” Jennifer C. Warren with a high powered rifle at close range as she begged for her life in a remote field in eastern El Paso County.

Sylvester’s public defenders requested a new trial. They argued that jurors should have known about allegations of drug dealing by a woman they contend had more motive to kill Warren.

Watch Gazette.com for the full story.

Jury finds Sylvester guilty of second-degree murder

April 22nd, 2010, 2:39 pm by

Marc Thomas Sylvester

A jury today found Marc Thomas Sylvester guilty of second-degree murder of a Colorado Springs woman who was shot  in the head with a high-powered rifle.

However, the  jurors acquitted Sylvester of all other charges, including first-degree murder, robbery and second-degree kidnapping.

The verdict was an emotional moment for some of the jurors, who asked for more time before they came into the courtroom to deliver their decision.

The jurors had been in their third day of deliberation in the trial, which started on March 31.

Sylvester was accused in the Feb. 9, 2009 murder of Jennifer C. Warren, 35, whose body was discovered in a wind-blown ditch in eastern El Paso County.

 She had been shot in the head at close range with a high-powered rifle in what prosecutors described as an execution-style killing.

Prosecutors showed jurors a videotaped confession in which Sylvester told a sheriff’s detective “I think it was me” and demonstrated how he held the rifle used to kill Warren.

Judge Robert Lowrey. Photos by Mark Reis, The Gazette

They also cited cell phone records that showed Sylvester’s phone was used in the area where the body was found, east of Schriever Air Force base near Book Drive and Milne Road.

But the public defenders representing Sylvester argued that it was a false confession obtained under duress from the 39-year-old former truck driver.

They argued that a woman named Elizabeth Angel had more motivation to kill Warren than their client. They claimed that Angel suspected her husband had an affair with Warren. They also claimed that Warren got Angel’s husband arrested by snitching on him.

Angel admitted she assaulted Warren in a motorcycle garage earlier that evening but insisted she had nothing to do with the murder.

Sylvester faces between 16 to 48 years in prison when Fourth Judicial District Judge Robert L. Lowrey sentences him on June 1.

Deputy Public Defender Rose Roy declined comment on the verdict until the sentencing.

Kathleen Walsh, a spokeswoman for the District Attorney’s office, said prosecutors thank the jury for what was “a difficult decision.”

“While he (Sylvester) is in prison, we hope he never has a chance to hurt another member of the community,” Walsh said.

Members of Warren’s family who attended nearly every day of the trial left the courtroom via a back entrance without comment.

No verdict yet in Sylvester murder trial

April 21st, 2010, 4:08 pm by

Marc Thomas Sylvester. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette

 

Jurors in the first-degree murder trial of Marc Thomas Sylvester have recessed without a verdict following their second day of deliberations.

The jury began deliberations on Friday, then recessed for four days before resuming this morning.

Sylvester is accused in the execution-style slaying of Jennifer C. Warren, who was found shot in the head with a high-powered rifle in a ditch in eastern El Paso County.

Deliberations will resume tomorrow. Stay with the Sidebar for news of the verdict.

Sylvester murder trial deliberations resume

April 21st, 2010, 9:45 am by
Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Sylvester trial resumes this afternoon

April 8th, 2010, 8:24 am by
Please enable Javascript and Flash to view this Brightcove video.

Scenes from the Sylvester murder trial

April 7th, 2010, 7:53 am by

Marc Thomas Sylvester in court on Tuesday. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette.

Good morning court watchers,

This is John Ensslin, legal affairs reporter for the Gazette.

This morning, I’ll be live blogging from the first-degree murder trial of Marc Thomas Sylvester.

Sylvester is accused of killing Jennifer C. Warren, 35, with a high-powered rifle in February 2009.

Today’s testimony will feature an interesting confrontation.

A woman named Elizabeth Marie Angel is on the witness stand.

Sylvester’s public defenders contend that Angel had more of a motive to kill Warren than their client.

In testimony so far, Angel has denied any role in the killing.

She did admit beating up Warren in a confrontation in a motorcycle garage the day before Warren’s murder.

She was sentenced to probation for her guilty plea in that assault.

This morning the jury listened to an expletive-laden tape recording of a series of conversations Angel had with her husband Jason, who was in jail at the time on an unrelated charge of attempted murder.

On the tape, Angel complains that her husband had been unfaithful to her. She tells him about the confrontation she had with Warren, whom she suspected had been sleeping with her husband.

“She was on her (expletive) knees saying what a (expletive) she was,” Angel said. “I could (expletive) take her life.”

That conversation occurred on Feb. 9th, the day that investigators discovered Warren’s body in a ditch on the edge of a remote field in eastern El Paso County. She had been shot in the head with a high-powered rifle.

There had been testimony earlier in the trial that Warren had snitched on Jason Angel and landed him in jail.

Elizabeth Angel had testified that Sylvester had called her on Feb. 9 to say, “the (expletive) will not talk again,” referring to Warren.

When she asked what he meant, she said Sylvester cut her off and hung up.

 Today, jurors listened to a tape from Feb. 10 when Elizabeth Angel told her husband what had happened.

Here are some excerpts from that conversation:

Jason: Why would the (expletive) weirdo call and tell you he did it?

Elizabeth: I don’t know…

Jason: I’m tripping…What’s he going to say when he gets arrested? Is he going to bring you into it?

Elizabeth: He’d better not.

Jason: Who is this (expletive) weirdo anyway?

Elizabeth: I don’t (expletive) know….

 Jason: Did he rape her or some (expletive?)

 Elizabeth: I don’t know. I don’t know.

Jason: I think you should say something before he tries to bring you into it…I think you should go to the (expletive) police. Who the (expletive) is he anyway? She (Warren) didn’t deserve that (expletive.)

Elizabeth: I know that.

Jason: As long as you didn’t (expletive) do it with him.

Elizabeth: No I didn’t.

Jason: Then you should just go to the cops. They’re going to find out….This guy’s a (expletive) idiot….You better take a lawyer with you….Why the (expletive) did he do that (expletive.)

 Elizabeth: I don’t know. I don’t know.

Jason: …Do you think they’re going to arrest you?

Elizabeth: I haven’t done anything.

Jason: I hope not. I told you I didn’t like that (expletive) weirdo. I’m going to (expletive) him up when he gets in here.”

Elizabeth Angel testified that she was in the process of talking to a lawyer when police contacted and interviewed her.

The trial has recessed for lunch. I’ll end this live blog here.

Sylvester murder trial resumes

April 6th, 2010, 1:29 pm by

Marc Thomas Sylvester at his first-degree murder trial this morning. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette

Testimony has resumed this afternoon in the first-degree murder trial of Marc Thomas Sylvester.

This morning jurors watched a videotape that crime scene investigators took of the field where they found Jennifer C. Warren’s body on Feb. 9, 2009.

The camera pans across the windswept field along Book Drive in eastern El Paso County. There’s a farm house in the distance and mountains to the west. The wind is intense as it whips the yellow crime scene tape.

Warren’s body could be seen laying in a ditch between dirt road and a barb wire fence. She had been shot in the head. Her sandal-clad feet pointed toward the road.

This afternoon,  a witness  is identifying a hunting rifle that he lent to Sylvester in December 2008.

Live from the Sylvester murder trial

April 6th, 2010, 8:12 am by

Jennifer C. Warren

Good morning court watchers,

This is John Ensslin, legal affairs reporter for the Gazette.

This morning, I’ll be live blogging from the first-degree murder trial of Marc Thomas Sylvester.

So far today’s testimony is centered on the crime scene investigation of a field in eastern El Paso County east of Schreiver Air Force Base.

That’s where authorities found the body of Jennifer C. Warren on Feb. 9, 2009.

Pete Quick, a technician with the Metro Crime Lab, and former homicide detective, is the first witness today.

He’s describing some of the challenges investigators faced at the scene, particularly from the weather.

“It was very difficult,” Quick said. “It was very windy.”

“We couldn’t use the crime scene placards that you see on television,” he added. “The wind was so powerful that it would just blow away our placards.”

Later in the investigation when the wind died down, they were able to return to the scene and used placards to document it.

Quick described how metal detectors were used to search for the bullet that killed Warren.

Previous testimony indicated the shot was fired from a high-powered rifle.

Warren died of a gunshot to the head.

 Investigators found a couple of gold hoop style earrings that appeared to belong to the victim, Quick said.

But they were never able to recover the bullet. At the time, they had no way to know the angle of how the rifle was pointed when fired. Besides the metal detectors, investigators also dug holes and sifted through the dirt, to no avail.

Prosecutor Jack Roth, left, uses a pointer to question crime scene technician Peter Quick about bullet trajectories this morning during the first-degree murder trial of Marc Thomas Sylvester. Photo by Mark Reis, The Gazette.

“You could use the needle in a haystack analogy because that’s similar to what it would be,” Quick he said. “The projectile could have gone anywhere in that field within several hundred yards.”

Quick also described a search that investigators conducted five days later in a motorcycle repair shop called the Chop Shop in the 2300 block of East Platte Avenue of Colorado Springs. He showed photos of several blood spots found on the floor of the garage.

According to previous testimony, the shop was the scene of an assault on Warren prior to her murder.

Under cross examination by Deputy Public Defender Cindy Hyatt, quick also described strands of blood-stained hair found on the floor of the garage as well as six 9mm bullets that were recovered from elsewhere in the shop.

I’ll be taking a break here and resuming this blog later today.